Untold lessons from the first Thanksgiving
When the Pilgrims arrived on the New England coast in 1620, a glorious chapter of freedom and liberty was born in the annals of history. What is generally ignored and unknown, however, is the fact that this landing at Massachusetts Bay marked the first Socialist settlement in America. This experiment in collectivist theory failed within three years time, and to survive, the Pilgrims had to turn to what we now know as the free enterprise system.
Under the Mayflower Compact, a temporary agreement to keep the law and order, Plymouth was set up as a “share-the-wealth” community. Nobody owned anything. Whatever was produced belonged to the community as a whole. They called this system “the common course and condition.” They lived under this system from the first desperate winter of 1620-21, until the hungry spring of 1623. They then discovered the empowering realities of private enterprise.
In his book “Of Plymouth Plantation” the colony’s second governor, William Bradford, wrote, “The Pilgrims weren’t long under this ‘common course and condition, until it was found to breed much confusion and discontent, and retard much employment that would have been to their benefit and comfort.”
Instead of a Thanksgiving feast in the fall of 1622, there was literal starvation and hopelessly low morale. Bradford continues, “At last, after much debate of things, the governor (Bradford himself) gave way that they should set corn every man for his own particular…and so assigned to every family a parcel of land.” They could keep everything they were able to grow on their own land. “This had very good success for it made ill hands very industrious, so as much more corn was planted than other wise would have been,” concluded Bradford.
The Pilgrims offered thanks for deliverance from starvation (and collectivism) with a great Thanksgiving feast in the fall of 1623. It was then that the Indians joined them in celebration.
As Mark Alexander writes in the Patriot Post, “The conclusion was obvious. Given liberty and incentive to be industrious, their Colony thrived. Indeed, by 1624, production was so abundant that the Colony exported corn back to England.”
This is the true story of the Pilgrims that should be taught in every classroom in America, because socialism has failed every time it has been tried over the centuries. Socialism is always destined to fail because it violates certain fundamental economic and moral laws that simply cannot be violated.
As Americans gather at the dinner table this Thanksgiving, it would be wise to consider the direction our nation is headed and the suffering that will commence, unless the lessons of history are brought to light and our leaders are held accountable to them.
May God richly bless you and your family this Thanksgiving and may we all remember to give thanks for this exceptional land of liberty and the heavy price that’s been paid to secure it.
Sourced from “A Thanksgiving Story” by Thurman Sensing

